In 1913 the US, in response to several economic panics, created our central bank, the Federal Reserve. As most of you are aware the President and Congress do not determine US monetary policy or interest rates; that is the function of the Federal Reserve. And although the US Treasury actually controls the printing presses, the Federal Reserve actually determines the amount of money available in the economy, by various means, and ultimately can “buy” dollars from the US Treasury for the cost of printing, about 6 cents per bill printed.
Ben Bernanke is the current chairman of the Fed, and as you are no doubt aware he has taken two critical actions since our economy headed south several years ago. First, he lowered the federal funds rate to essentially zero. That means banks can borrow money from the Fed for zero percent interest, which has the net effect of keeping interest rates very low throughout the economy. That is why your savings account pays you nothing, and that is also why mortgage rates are at historical lows.
The second thing Mr. Bernanke has done is to expand the money supply through a mechanism they like to call “quantitative easing”, or QE as it is called. This has been done more than once and so we now have labels such as QE1, QE2, etc. to describe Fed programs that essentially put more money into the economy. Currently the Fed is buying $85 billion dollars worth of US Treasury bonds each month, with money it has the US Treasury print. When they buy those bonds they introduce more actual US currency into the system, and also create demand for the Treasury notes, allowing the US to “borrow” more money and go deeper in debt. When the US Government sells it’s bonds, or “debt”, someone has to buy it, and they hold auctions to sell them. When the Fed buys back $85 billion per month they enhance the demand and the price the government gets when it sells bonds, which helps the government and allows them to keep selling their debt.
So far Mr. Bernanke’s strategy has worked. Despite concerns voiced by people such as Larry Kudlow that such a policy would send inflation soaring, Larry recently admitted that things have not turned out that way. Inflation remains low, the stock market has more than doubled, and the economy is improving. Indeed, housing prices are on the rise, and although there are still housing concerns, the market has improved dramatically and many markets are seeing better prices and not as many homeowners are upside down. Likewise the industrial sector is doing better, with a pretty good earnings season and healthy profits in many areas. Despite concerns about a weaker dollar, the dollar has actually done well compared to other currencies. And unemployment has declined somewhat and although not at healthy levels is not a grim as it has been. So far, so good.
When you listen to the pundits on CNBC, Bloomberg, or Fox Business, they describe the Fed’s QE programs as “the punch bowl”. Many people think that all of the good news above is a result of Mr. Bernanke’s actions, and they all worry about what will happen when the Fed removes the punch bowl. In fact, as is usual with any Fed chairman, they search for subtle clues in the language and tone the chairman uses with every speech, to see if there is any hint that they may cut back on QE or “take away the punch bowl”. That happened this week, and markets reacted immediately, only to pare some of the losses later in the day. You see, with interest rates this low, putting your money someplace usually safe, like bonds, is actually a risky thing to do. That is because if you are holding a bond that pays 1% and suddenly interest rates go up and bonds then pay 5%, nobody will want to buy your 1% bond and the price, or value, of your bond will go down. If you are invested in a bond fund when rates drop, you will lose money. Likewise, if you have had your money under a mattress, not only are you risking inflation losses, but you have missed out on fantastic gains in the stock market, which if you ever want to retire you simply cannot do. When the market goes up you need to be invested or it does you no good.
And so the lament of everyone involved in the investment world is, “if you pull your money out of the market, where else are you going to put it?” And as a result, everyone keeps buying stocks, driving up stock prices and even preventing a healthy “correction”, because every dip is a buying opportunity. This is exactly what Mr. Bernanke was counting on, because when the stock market goes up real wealth is created, and people use that wealth to buy things, and the economy improves.
However….and you knew the however was coming….all of this misses a couple of critical points. First, the fact that inflation has not risen does not mean it is not going to. We can examine the technical factors ad infinitum, but in the end more dollars means dollars are going to be worth less. There are some reasons for the strong dollar and lack of inflation, for example other governments are inflating their own money supply (Japan on purpose), and eventually these factors will not overcome the fact that we have printing presses belching out currency at a phenomenal rate.
Second, when the Fed removes the punch bowl there will be an immediate and strong reaction. The market will drop, perhaps precipitously. I think initially there will be a correction and then people will see a buying opportunity, but you had better be able to ride it out and be in for the long haul. As I pointed out earlier, bonds and bond funds will also take a massive hit, and that means everyone will take a hit, as there is really no safe haven. I think the underlying economy is stronger, and so people will realize that and get back in, but the psychology of the market is beyond anyone to predict or understand, so these are guesses. I hope there is not some world event that coincides, as then all bets are off.
These are concerns, but here is the real concern; currently the largest debtor in the world is enjoying a huge savings from the lowest interest rates in history. The US government is SEVENTEEN TRILLION DOLLARS in debt, and the fact that interest rates are low is helping to dramatically lower the amount we pay every year for interest on the national debt. Bernanke is aware of this, but at some point he will have to battle inflation, and take away the punch bowl. When inflation rises, it will hurt the home buyer, or anyone who must refinance, but the biggest concern will be the interest paid by the federal government on our national debt. When we have to pay higher interest on seventeen trillion dollars worth of debt, we are going to be in trouble and balancing the federal budget may become nearly impossible. Sequestration has merely slowed the rate of borrowing, but we are still borrowing money. Most corporations have slashed costs and are buying back their own stock, and even the states are doing much better at managing their budgets, for the most part. But the federal government in it’s arrogance has barely begun to get it’s house in order. We must address entitlements, and do so now. The punch bowl will only be around so long, and instead of using this opportunity to get our house in order, we just keep borrowing more money.